The Silent Treatment Toxic relationship pattern

The Silent Treatment in Relationships

The Silent Treatment In Relationships

The silent treatment is deliberately withdrawing communication from your partner when you’re angry, hurt or unhappy with them. Instead of saying what the problem is, you stop engaging and make your displeasure known through silence.

It doesn’t always mean refusing to speak altogether. Someone can answer practical questions about the kids or what time they’re leaving while shutting down everything else. They might ignore you when you speak, avoid eye contact, leave the room when you enter or withdraw affection. What makes it particularly obvious is when they continue talking normally to everyone else while barely acknowledging you.

The silent treatment can last for a few hours or several days. In some relationships, the person eventually starts talking again when their anger passes. In others, the silence continues until their partner makes the first move, apologises or does something to get things back to normal.

Read: 4 Communication Styles That Ruin a Relationship

Signs of the Silent Treatment

The silent treatment can include:

When this becomes a familiar response to conflict, you’re no longer looking at one person being quiet because they’re pissed off. You’re looking at a relationship pattern.

Read: 10 Toxic Relationship Patterns

Why Do People Use the Silent Treatment?

People use the silent treatment for different reasons.

Some people struggle badly with conflict. They can communicate when everything is going well, but anger is harder. They shut down because they don’t know how to explain what they’re feeling or stay in a conversation once emotions run high.

Attachment style can play a part here. Someone with an avoidant attachment style can withdraw when emotional conversations feel too intense or when they feel pressured to talk before they’re ready. That doesn’t mean avoidant attachment automatically causes the silent treatment, but withdrawal can become part of the way they respond to conflict.

Other people learned the behaviour growing up. Anger in their family meant people stopped speaking to each other. Nobody sat down and sorted anything out. Someone withdrew, everyone knew they were angry and eventually the atmosphere returned to normal. That becomes their model for dealing with conflict.

Read: 10 Signs of Trauma Bonding in Relationships

Then there are people who expect their partner to know why they’re angry. They don’t explain what has upset them because they believe they shouldn’t have to. Their partner is left trying to work out what they said, what they did or what they failed to notice.

The silent treatment can also be deliberate punishment. Someone knows ignoring their partner hurts and uses silence to show their anger, get an apology or make the other person back down. This can also appear within narcissistic relationship patterns, where withdrawing attention and affection becomes another way to punish or control a partner.

Those motivations are very different, which is why the behaviour needs to be understood in the context of the whole relationship rather than judged from one episode.

When the Silent Treatment Becomes a Toxic Relationship Pattern

The biggest concern isn’t one argument where somebody goes quiet. It’s what happens when silence becomes normal in the relationship.

You know the routine before it has even played out.

Something happens and your partner’s mood changes. They stop talking. You ask what’s wrong and get nothing useful back. The tension sets in and you know you’re in for another round of being ignored.

Eventually you start recognising what sets it off. Certain subjects. Disagreeing with them. Challenging something they’ve said. Asking a question they don’t want to answer. Telling them you’re unhappy about something.

That’s where the silent treatment starts compounding with another toxic relationship pattern: walking on eggshells.

You begin thinking ahead before you speak. Is this worth bringing up? Are they going to shut me out again? Do I really want another weekend ruined by this?

You might decide to leave something alone because you can’t face the reaction. You soften what you were going to say. You wait for a better mood. You apologise just to end it.

The silent treatment hasn’t started yet, but it’s already influencing you.

That’s what makes repeated patterns so damaging. Your behaviour begins changing around someone else’s reaction. Instead of saying what you think or talking about  something that matters to you, you know it’s not worth the trouble so you just don’t bother. 

The Impact of the Silent Treatment

Being ignored by someone you love can leave you angry, rejected, confused and incredibly frustrated. Knowing what it feels like to get the silent treatment makes you overthink everything and you change your own behaviour to avoid the fall out.

For someone with an anxious attachment style, that sudden withdrawal can hit particularly hard. The loss of connection can trigger the fear that the relationship itself is under threat, which can create an even stronger urge to chase, apologise or get the other person talking again.

That can create an unhealthy combination when one partner responds to conflict by withdrawing and the other responds to withdrawal by desperately trying to restore connection. The more one person chases, the more the other can pull away. Neither person is dealing with the issue that caused the conflict.

When the silent treatment is being used as punishment, the impact goes further. The person giving it controls when normal interaction resumes. The person receiving it is left waiting, guessing or trying to make peace.

After enough episodes, ending the silence can become more important than resolving the disagreement.

You apologise because you’re exhausted. The house feels normal again, but the original issue hasn’t gone anywhere.

And that’s how resentment builds.

The Silent Treatment Doesn't Resolve Relationship Conflict

Silence can end an argument without resolving a single thing.

If the disagreement was about trust, money, sex, parenting, an affair or something one partner has done, the issue is still sitting there when the silence ends. The couple may start speaking again because life has to continue, but that doesn’t mean the problem has been dealt with.

After a couple of days of tension, neither person may want to bring it up again. There’s relief in getting back to normal and nobody wants to risk another round.

So it gets shoved under the carpet. Then the next problem shoved under the carpet too.

Over time, the relationship can become full of subjects nobody wants to touch because everyone knows where they lead. Communication becomes smaller and safer. The couple might even argue less, but not because the relationship is healthier. They’re avoiding the conversations most likely to cause trouble.

The silent treatment then starts sitting alongside the other toxic patterns already happening in the relationship. One person may be walking on eggshells, another may be withdrawing whenever conflict becomes uncomfortable, or the silence may form part of a wider pattern of narcissistic behaviour, control or emotional manipulation.

That’s why the silent treatment needs to be looked at as part of the whole relationship.

When it becomes the standard response to anger, it doesn’t just stop conversation for a few days. It changes what gets discussed, what gets avoided and how safe each person feels expressing themselves.

If the silent treatment has become part of a wider toxic pattern in your relationship, relationship counselling can help you understand what is happening between you and address the issues that continue to sit underneath the silence.

You May Be Interested in These Related Articles

Whitsunday Professional Counselling is not a Crisis support service. For crisis support, please contact 000 or Lifeline: 13 11 14

Picture of Mirella DeBoni

Mirella DeBoni

I’m Mirella DeBoni!
Wife, Mum and Relationship Counsellor for the past 18 years.... Living in the beautiful Whitsundays.
I support people who want to work things out in their relationship, are trying to decide if it’s time to walk away, or are rebuilding their life after a relationship ends.